Polkinghorne sobs in court as 111 call played again to jury

Kim Baker Wilson Kim Baker Wilson | 09-19 08:20

Murder-accused Philip Polkinghorne has placed his head in his hands, loudly sobbing as his 111 call to report his wife's death in April 2021 was again played to jurors.

The 71-year-old's face was red as he grabbed for tissues next to his desk at the High Court in Auckland.

His crying intensified and pierced the courtroom, forcing a break within seconds of the playback ending, and he was guided away by security, still crying.

Shortly before the 111 call, the jury officially retired to consider his fate.

Jurors are deciding whether to back the Crown's version of events that he fatally strangled Pauline Hanna and made it look like a suicide, or whether to back Polkinghorne's defence that his wife ended her own life and he found her already dead.

ADVERTISEMENT

The jury retired at 10.23am.

The 11 jury members headed for the jury room carrying large armfuls of documents and folders.

Some briefly returned to collect handfuls of pens and highlighters.

After the break for Polkinghorne, he and the jurors returned to the courtroom to again hear a recording of Hanna's voice from 2019.

This was the so-called Longlands Recording, the recording made while she was talking to family at her brother's home in Hawke's Bay.

For some time, Polkinghorne's head was again in his hands.

Hanna's voice rang across the courtroom, calling her husband "an angry man" while Polkinghorne sat with his eyes closed.

ADVERTISEMENT

At one point, she called him hurtful.

But at another point in the recording, Hanna said, "I am his brick, he is mine" and that she loves him.

While listening to the recording, Polkinghorne grabbed for some more tissues.

He sat looking down and forward with his chin resting in his hands.

The jury then returned to the jury room after the Longlands Recording finished playing.

Just ahead of both recordings being played, Justice Graham Lang detailed for the jury the so-called non-specific injuries Hanna had on her body. It's uncertain how they happened.

The injuries on Hanna were:

More on this topic

Polkinghorne a grieving husband, not a 'master manipulator' – defence

Philip Polkinghorne's trial for the alleged murder of his wife Pauline Hanna is drawing closer to its end.

Crime and Justice

Wednesday 12:35pm

Polkinghorne murder trial: Two questions the jury must answer

After weeks of statements and submissions, the jury is now set to begin its deliberations in the former eye surgeon's high-profile trial.

Crime and Justice

Wednesday 5:33pm

Polkinghorne's defence on 'the murder the police wrote'

Ron Mansfield told jurors Philip Polkinghorne would have to be "a highly efficient and trained killer" to leave someone dead without any telltale signs.

Crime and Justice

Tue, Sep 17

  • Four bruises to her left arm.
  • A 5cm x 2cm bruise to her right temple.
  • A scrape to her back.
  • An abrasion to her nose.

The trial, originally expected to last six weeks, is now in its eighth.

Disclaimer: The copyright of this article belongs to the original author. Reposting this article is solely for the purpose of information dissemination and does not constitute any investment advice. If there is any infringement, please contact us immediately. We will make corrections or deletions as necessary. Thank you.


ALSO READ

KSE-100 index closes at 81,459.29, up 997.95 points as investor optimism drives market

The Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) experienced a surge in investor optimism on Thursday, as the bench...

Gold prices in Pakistan reach new record of Rs268,500 per tola

Following a decline in the previous session, gold prices in Pakistan experienced a significant incre...

Number of clinical health staff increasing - Health NZ

Health officials have been marking the growth in the number of full-time clinical roles as evidence ...

Hazard mapping has 'chilling effect' on Nelson property market

Proposed hazard maps for Nelson are allegedly preventing properties across the city from being insur...

Woman called 'bad mum' after chasing down child stealer

A woman who stole an 18-month-old baby told the girl's mother she didn't deserve children when confr...

'Weak' case against diabetic driver thrown out by Australian court

A magistrate has criticised prosecutors as he threw out their "weak" case against a diabetic driver ...